Printer Ink Study Project 5

Nearing the end of this fun project.  Everyone is jealous that I was selected and that I got to print so many pictures.  (I didn’t tell them that as part of the study many pictures are the same, just looking for differences over time.)

This week’s project included printing a Power Point presentation on both printers and comparing.  Both printers did a good job with the colors.  I saw the persistent banding on the refill prints, when looking very carefully, but they would have been acceptable for a project.  The bigger thing was that I ran out of black ink half way through the last page.  The print below is the HP ink.  If you look closely there are some lines but they are on the scanner, not the print.  So, two things: First, I have used twice as much ink during this project, to date.  There is still ink in the HP printer. (I just looked–slightly under half of the color is left and 90% of the black).  The second thing is that my frugal nature would not generally allow me to print a picture with so much black background.  Though it does look good.

In addition to the Power Point I printed my every week photos and did not notice much difference in quality.   The green of the refill is definitely darker…would it bother me?  Probably not.  The streaking or banding lines would bother me more.

Also this week we were asked to print out any business jobs we might have.  One of my most particular customers (okay, my mom) asked me to print up some flyers for their raffle.  All the prints came out similarly.  I felt the Refill ink was a little more blurry in some of the small detail areas.  Though you can see the text on the photo came out crisp on both pictures.  Notice the red text though. The photo on the left is HP ink. I picked a red based on the quilt color and the HP print is very much like my choice.  On the right, though, the Refill ink color is much more brown.  I’m not really sure why as the quilt colors, particularly the reds look similar. 

Now, as you admire this quilt you may be thinking it would be fun to have.  Give me a shout and I’ll set you up with some raffle tickets.  In fact, if you win and live out of state, I’ll spring for the shipping.  The drawing is in February coordinated with our state centennial celebration.   Your donation will go to help the club find more prospecting sites out in the Quartzsite area.

So to recap:  This week I ran out of black ink.  I can purchase HP brand for about $30 a cartridge (or less as I have seen lots of 20% off ads).  Each color refill cost $15, the black is $10.  Plus three trips to the store.  And don’t forget that one of the color cartridges had contaminated colors.  I thought I was being smart saving money with the refill cartridges but  this side by side challenge has showed me the error of my ways.  So week 5 score HP 5 = Refill 0

Printer Ink Study Week 2

This week’s project was fun! I got to print a bunch of pictures and compare the HP Ink to the Refilled Cartridge. No problems with the refill cartridge and at first I thought both printers were equal quality. Then I looked at them in better light. The colors were similar with both print (green seems to be more definitive on the Refill Ink print) but there was definite banding on the refill print. It is not obvious; look close at the pants on the right and you can see the lines.

 These lines were visible on all the pictures I printed today.  Also on the list for today was to print some stock pictures that will be compared each week. Side by side the colored photos were very similar both to comparing HP to Refill and to last weeks. But, there was a big difference between B&W picture from last week to this.

Both Refill Ink Photos. Week 1 on top.

The B&W photo from this week is much more what I would expect the gray scale to be. Week 1, in comparison is almost sepia tone.

The final project this week was to print a project from the HP website. I found a terrific calendar with lots of red and room for a photo. Both pictures printed very similar colors but the Refill Ink had definite banding.

Refill Ink on Left — HP Ink on Right

 Before I print again I am going to do a ink head cleaning with the Refill Cartridge. Of course, downside to this is that it uses up my ink. So the end result: Week 2= HP Wins!